You know, Mass
Effect has always had an interesting relationship with gender dynamics
throughout its games. The series seemed to continually zig-zag between one bias
or another occasionally, but often trying to maintain some semblance of equality
between the party members and major figures. That is until the third game in
which the introduction of one character seemed to result in some rather
disturbing ideas.
Now, I want
to make one thing clear before starting on this: I do not universally side with
one gender or another when it comes to problems or representation and equality.
I’ll always try to argue for the group I think is losing out the most either in
terms of equality or with facts simply being blatantly overlooked or ignored.To give examples from the comicbook industry I agree that the use of female characters as fan-service is still a major problem as are situations of women in refrigerators. At the same time I’ll also point out frequent occurrences where fan-service has happened to men without complaints or uproar and where women in refrigerators has happened to male characters. One prime example being where the father of Robin, Jack Drake, was murdered during Identity Crisis for little to no reason besides to create angst for Robin’s character. I have criticised the rampant use of rape with female characters as the driving force for a plot such as, again Identity Crisis, with Sue Dibny. At the same time I’ve heavily criticised how media downplays acts of sexual or physical abuse towards male characters, such as Devin Grayson’s mishandled female-on-male rape of Nightwing and refusal to acknowledge it for what it really was.
One of the
biggest criticisms I keep making of Warhammer 40,000 is how it is
seemingly phasing the only all-female army, the Sisters of Battle, out of the
universe. Only using them when they need someone to get brutally killed to make
another army look tougher and taking things a step further in the sixth edition, removing any mention of the Sisters of Silence.
To give a few
examples from the Mass Effect universe itself, one big complaint I made
as the series developed was the objectification of female characters. While
this was true for a lot of the romance options in Mass Effect 2, such as
Jacob wearing a skin tight bodysuit and Thane walking around with his chest
bare, it was often taken several steps further with a couple of female
characters. With Jack effectively being half naked the entire time, and the
game’s camera giving so many arse shots of Miranda it has become a running gag
within the series’ fandom and something even the writers joked about. Not to
mention the massive criticisms of Ashley’s appearance when she returned in in
third game.
The point is
I try to be fair with any gender criticisms no matter which side they’re
directed towards. Were the roles of each gender reversed in what I am about to
talk about, I would be making the exact same complaints. As such I don’t want
to see anyone accusing this article of being chauvinistic, misogynistic or
blind to inequalities.
The criticism
I’m about to make, and of the universe as a whole only came to light a short
time ago. Re-watching a few of Mass
Effect 3’s cutscenes I made sure to see some of the dialogue from Eve, the
female krogan who might hold the key to reversing the sterility virus inflicted
upon their species. Mostly because of
the fact I’d ended up skipping over her accidently during my own playthrough.
Now, most of the character was fine. Her dialogue was well written, had an
interesting backstory, she was extremely well voice acted and she was a strong,
likable character. At least until she started to get onto the subject of gender
with this line when she is talking about possible attempts for revenge against
the genophage:
“It’s not in
the nature of our males to co-operate. They’ve evolved to me selfish, their
only concern is survival.”Now, until this point Eve has been talking about the krogan as a whole. Every act they have taken has been about all of them no matter which gender they belong to, not going into specifics and yet now when pushed she suddenly starts to label only males with any negative connotations. This suggests she at least thinks the female krogan were completely immune to this, that somehow they never became selfish, hoarding or even the territorial aspects they “evolved” to survive because their world was a resource starved hellhole.
This seems
like a massive contradiction to the little information we had previously about
the females like codex events with female krogan warlords where they were
detailed as being effectively the same in their mentality and aspects as the
males. They were suggested to be just as violent, just as bull-headed and were
a part of events like the krogan rebellions and it wasn’t simply the males who
were causing the problems in their society so much as their culture, mentality
and traditions. And this only gets worse as she continues to speak:
“Wrex is
different, he’s a mutant. And that you can tell him.”This comes right after that last line. Wrex is an exception, something not often seen – that’s something the series always stated but the big change here is how he is one. When you encounter him in the first game Wrex is jaded, bitter and has no illusions to how far his race has fallen. He’s become disillusioned with their culture, society and all aspects which have them desiring to get revenge for what was done to them hundreds of years ago and pointlessly fight everyone. He was suggested to be different from the average krogan. This conversation, taking into account that last line, says now he’s only different from the average male krogan leader. This is only reinforced when she goes on to talk about how things will change after the genophage is cured:
“Our species
will find its balance again.
Females will
help shape the future like in the ancient days, before we were just pawns of
power hungry males.”
Again, this
is a titanic contradiction to a previously universal presentation
of their species suggesting that women have no power in their society and, once
again, the males are only to blame for their current state. Every mention of
the krogan we’ve had in the past suggested females had considerable power,
living separately from the others in their own clans and raising new krogan.
With males only being allowed to occasionally see those they sired,
they’re not used as trophies or pawns they seemed to have actual power in their
society. There’s more to this but I’ll speak about that later on. She just keeps bringing up how krogan males
mistreat their females, something highlighted by this exchange when Shepard
asks about her treatment:
“How has
Mordin been treating you?”“Better than krogan males do, he’s not like a typical salarian.”
Apparently even giving a damn about her health is something beyond anything any krogan male might do even if, as she claims, they regard her kind only as ways of boosting their power. Someone wouldn’t be much of a trophy if they were dead after all. And she just keeps going on about how everything is the fault of only the males, to the point where she starts to even contradict herself:
“Rivalries
are the invention of the males. Under their rule Tuchanka has laid in ruins for
over a thousand years.
It’s time
females took back our places in society and resurrected our future.”
Now let’s
just make this clear: For a race who is built like tanks, can be driven into a
berserker like state, who are violent and all of who are combat capable
regardless of gender: rivalries are something invented by the males.
No,
apparently they weren’t created when their society bombed itself back into the
stone age. Not prior to the genophage when their entire society wouldn’t have had reasons to place so much value upon females.
Not when they were formed into clans thousands of years old with traditions fighting over resources in the most inhospitable post-apocalyptic planet in the entire galaxy where there would have been no difference in gender roles. And their lack of rebuilding has nothing to do with their lack of numbers, resources or the fact they were almost completely reliant upon the salarians for knowledge of tech when they uplifted them from a barbaric state.
No, apparently their fragmented society only turned in on itself a relatively short while ago and rather than it being something their whole race can be blamed for, it’s only the fault of the ones who have dicks. And every single last problem will be corrected once females retake control.
As if this were not enough it’s capped off with this little gem, if you’re playing a female Shepard anyway:
“I’m glad to see humans treat their women with respect. Your people have placed a lot of responsibility on you.”
“No more than yours have on you”
“Then maybe we can show the men how it’s done.”
That last
line might have been amusing were it not for what preceded it, something joked
about to relieve tension. Instead it comes across as her believing that due to
her gender she is naturally superior and desires to prove how much better she
is innately to the males of her kind. What’s more is that line seems to suggest
females have no respect in her society at all. Now, rather than repeating the
previous points about how krogan females were presented as having power in
their society and a major role, let’s look at a more specific example of how
they were respected.
Those played Mass
Effect 2 might remember the krogan/vorcha enemies of the Blood Pack. A few
of you might have not looked into their history, it was listed outside the
gameplay after all, but it does show one very important thing about their
society: The krogan treat their females with a huge amount of respect. To quote
the wiki:
“The Blood
Pack was transformed into a mercenary legion by visionary krogan battlemaster
Ganar Wrang. Exiled for striking a female in anger, Wrang obsessed over
reclaiming his lost status.
Leading the
vorcha pack as a pirate crew, Wrang cultivated recruits and infamy for a decade
before incorporating his fighters as a security company across the Skyllian
Verge. His notoriety ensured his initial public offering for investors made him
rich beyond the krogan’s dreams. Wrang triumphantly returned to his clan,
rallying elders, krogan hordes, and their firepower and biotic support towards
professional violence in the Terminus Systems.”
So let’s make
this clear: The penalty for striking a female of a race who settles verbal
disputes with headbutts, have Wolverine-esq healing and can all but ignore
pain, is so severe the one who breaches this law is exiled. So severe that the
only act of glory and honour seen as being sufficient to allow his return was
to create one of the strongest PMC units in the entire galaxy. Yet in spite of
all this, Eve apparently claims the krogan women are treated with no respect.
Hell, if you
want a more visual example just take a look the scene where Eve is introduced
to the krogan in Mass Effect 3. Her presence is able to instantly stop a
dispute bordering upon violence. A few lines convinces both sides to support a
seemingly suicidal plan involving races they dispise, and no one even begins to
question her decision even though most have not even spoke with her prior to
then. If that is not a sign of respect and reverence I don’t know what is.
If it’s not
clear to you by this point, not only is this discussion a massive contradiction
to the previous portrayal of this species but it comes across as horrendously
sexist. It portrays every problem as only being the result of male krogan while
exonerates female krogan from any past negative action like the Rebellions.
Worst of all it seems to outright state “they will be better off under a
matriarchy where those childish, blind men are kept from becoming a danger to
everyone.” Each section where she
keeps making pot-shots at the males of her species. Blaming them for their
state feel out of place with her character and seems to contradict an otherwise
universal disillusionment with her race’s current state and how they need to be
guided. In no other scene does she single out one gender to be the blame for
all this and in all honestly this feels like it was written by someone
unfamiliar with the character. That or someone trying to push a political message.
Now, this was
bad. The message was grotesque and the obvious discrimination at play, with no
option to confront her and felt heavily insulting. However, it was only six
minutes of a several hour long game. I could understand fans wanting to
overlook it, but fan reaction to this seems to have been far worse. There seems
to have been only a very small number of people willing to call out this scene
on its blatant misandry, while almost all others have been accepting of it.
Calling it a sign of progress for equality, claiming it is acceptable and
ridiculing any who actually thinks a message of “women good, men evil”
is wrong. Here’s a few stand-out examples:
“Wanting women to be treated with respect = RIDICULOUS
OFFENSIVE FEMNAZI CHARACTER
Oh, gamers. “
“How is this offensive? It's science fiction. Krogan
males are overrun by testosterone (or aggression-inducing krogan hormones).
Krogan females are the wise ones in this species, I don't see anything
offensive there at all. More interestingly, I giggled a bit when Mordin labels
Abrahamic religions as "human mythology."”
“I'm a man and honestly, if any men found this offensive,
get a vasectomy. You should't breed and spread that sexist belief. Our women
have endured and still endure enough shit.”
This is quite
frankly disgusting. I would hope that no matter the gender, displays of open
discrimination and hatred would be rightfully criticised not defended with
claims of “sexism” to any who oppose it. There is a huge double standard at
work here. Imagine for a moment what the reaction would have been had it been
Wrex spouting lines like this:
“Rivalries are the invention of the females. Under their rule Tuchanka has laid in ruins for over a thousand years. It’s time males took back our places in society and resurrected our future.”
There would
have been an uproar, mass accusations at Bioware’s writers and the near universal
flipping of tables. You would have seen a huge demand for changes, insults
hurled at the creators, EA and anyone involved. Yet when the genders presented
as here it is seen as perfectly acceptable by both the fans and at least one
person involved in Mass Effect 3. You would not see people claiming that
because it is science fiction it is perfectly fine to create a species with
females who have barely any self-control who will only bring ruin to their
people when not led by a man.
Now, this
isn’t a demand for people to regard any negative portrayal of males as being
wrong or any such nonsense. It’s something highlighting where an otherwise well
written and relatively intelligent piece of media spectacularly failed. It’s a look
into the responses people seem to have to scenes like this and how some can be
blind to problems due to the roles of the races or genders involved. But most
of all it’s a request for any who read this to keep an open mind while
analysing moments like this. The next time you start to see something which
generalises blame and portrays a group with near universal negativity, think
for a few minutes how acceptable it would be if they were reversed.
If you feel
the need to comment or speak out against this then feel free, but I ask anyone
to read and most of all please think before you respond.
----
Mass Effect and all related characters and media are owned by Bioware and Electronic Arts.
----
Mass Effect and all related characters and media are owned by Bioware and Electronic Arts.
Recently started playing mass effect 3. Long time since I played mass effect 2 I had forgotten some of the krogan mythology.
ReplyDeleteSome things to point out:
When talking to wrex you can say something like:
"females have good ideas too". Do the Developers want us to believe that the krogan are sexist?
Wrex says females have "so many good ideas" and ... what male krogan don't?
Certain people will excuse anti-male biases by saying their male family and friends are different than men in general.
Thank you for writing about misandry in video games;
something that is completely ignored or ridiculed by the mainstream gaming press.
All that I do is ignore the conversation with Eve & Mordin on Normandy. In my 1st playthrough I didnt even come across it. I pretend the scenes dont exist.
ReplyDelete